Since August 10, 2005, the "Graves Amendment" has provided vehicle lessors and renters with a statut

Since August 10, 2005, the "Graves Amendment" london and day trips or weekend tours has provided vehicle lessors and renters with a statutory basis for dismissing vicarious london and day trips or weekend tours liability claims in motor vehicle accident lawsuits. In pertinent part, the Graves Amendment provides:
30106. Rented or leased motor vehicle safety responsibility(a) In general. An owner of a motor vehicle that rents or leases the vehicle to a person (or an affiliate of the owner) shall not be liable under the law of any State or political subdivision thereof, by reason of being the owner of the vehicle london and day trips or weekend tours (or an affiliate of the owner), for harm to persons or property that results london and day trips or weekend tours or arises london and day trips or weekend tours out of the use, operation, or possession london and day trips or weekend tours of the vehicle during the period of the rental or lease, if: (1) the owner (or an affiliate of the owner) is engaged in the trade or business of renting or leasing motor vehicles ; and(2) there is no negligence or criminal wrongdoing on the part of the owner (or an affiliate of the owner). ELRAC rented a car to Fernandez, who was involved in a motor vehicle accident in which the infant london and day trips or weekend tours plaintiff allegedly was injured. In an effort to avoid the claim-preclusive impact of the Graves Amendment, the plaintiffs in this case alleged in their complaint that ELRAC (Enterprise Rent-A-Car) negligently entrusted the rental vehicle to Fernandez london and day trips or weekend tours by failing to check his driving history. ELRAC answered and then moved to dismiss the plaintiffs' complaint based on the Graves Amendment.
The Court finds that the terms of the Graves Amendment validly apply here because the statute regulates and protects things in interstate commerce and because it regulates activity that substantially affected interstate commerce. Congress has legitimate authority under the Commerce Clause to regulate liability imposed upon a rental car company and the Graves london and day trips or weekend tours Amendment constitutionally preempted state laws that imposed vicarious liability on rental car companies (see, Garcia v. Vanguard Car Rental USA, Inc., 540 F.3d 1242 (11th Cir. 2008); Flagler v. Budget Rent a Car Systems, Inc ., 538 F. Supp. 2d 557 [ED NY 2008]). [FN3] [FN4] [FN5]
Clearly, the Graves Amendment voids Vehicle Traffic Law 388 to the extent that the Transportation Equity Act applies (see, Hall v. ELRAC, Inc., 52 AD3d 262 [1st Dept. 2008]); Hernandez v. Sanchez, 40 AD3d 446 [1st Dept. 2007]; Graham v. Dunkley, 50 AD3d 55 [2nd Dept. 2008]; Jones v. Bill, 34 AD3d 741 [2nd Dept. 2006], rev'd, 10 NY3d 550 [2008] [reversed on effective date of the amendment]; Williams v. White, 2007 Slip Op 02227 [3rd Dept. 2007]; Castillo v. Bradley, 17 Misc 3d 1107(A) [Sup. Ct. Kings 2008]; Infante london and day trips or weekend tours v. U-Haul Co. of Fla., 11 Misc 3d 529 [Sup. Ct. Queens 2006]).
Basing their claim upon the Graves Amendment, Defendants say the complaint against the corporation fails to state a cause of action because the allegations, if true, are barred london and day trips or weekend tours by the statute. In this regard, Defendants focus their attack upon Plaintiffs' allegation that ELRAC, Inc. was negligent because the corporation knew (or should have known) Fernandez's history of operating vehicles in an unsafe, london and day trips or weekend tours careless, and reckless manner (see, Complaint 10 to 12).
Construing liberally, as it must, Plaintiffs urge that the Court find that a claim is stated against the corporation london and day trips or weekend tours because the complaint alleges a cause of action under an exception to the Graves Amendment, i.e., actual negligence (49 U.S.C. 30106[a][2]). In this regard, by the statute's plain reading, while the Graves Amendment absolves rental car companies of vicarious liability, it does not absolve rental car companies for their own negligence (see generally, Novovic v. Greyhound Lines, london and day trips or weekend tours Inc., 2008 US Dist. Lexis 94176 [ED NY 2008]) (see also, American Association for Justice, AAJ Annual Convention Reference Materials, 2 Ann 2007 AAJ-CLE 1873 [2007]).
To decide whether ELRAC falls under the "own negligence" exception, the Court must decide whether the corporation was under an obligation to check Fernandez's driving record london and day trips or weekend tours and whether failure to carry out such duty places this case under the exemption provided by 49 USC 30106(a)(2) ("no negligence or criminal wrongdoing on the part of the owner").
Plaintiffs' allegations are limited to the following: (1) the corporate defendant had a duty to ensure that any vehicle rented by it would be operated in a safe manner; london and day trips or weekend tours (2) the corporate defendant london and day trips or weekend tours has a duty to determine whether any drivers to whom it rented vehicles did not have a history of operating vehicles in a careless way, and (3) ELRAC was negligent in renting to Fernandez (Complaint 9 to 11). Beyond that, no specifications london and day trips or weekend tours were made concerning the nature of Fernandez's driving record that should have alerted ELRAC not to rent to him.
In their answering papers, Plaintiffs generally argue that ELRAC was, in essence, guilty of "negligent entrustment," but cite no basis or any specifics for claiming that ELRAC was under a duty to check Fernandez's driving record.
At common law, owners could be held liable if they knowingly entrusted their car to an incompetent driver. "One who supplies a chattel london and day trips or weekend tours for the use of another whom the supplier knows or has reason to know to be likely because london and day trips or weekend tours of his youth, inexperience, or otherwise, to use it in a manner involving london and day trips or weekend tours unreasonable risk of physical harm to himself and others may be liable for negligent entrustment" (see, Pacho v. Enterprise Rent-A-Car Co., 572 F.Supp.2d 341 [SD NY 2008]) The Pacho Court found "negligent entrustment" applied to the rental company's failure london and day trips or weekend tours in that case to properly process the co-defendant's driver's license. However, in this case, no allegations exist that the corporate defendant failed to check Fernandez's london and day trips or weekend tours license. [FN6] Therefore, the Court must conclude that Plaintiffs failed to state a cause of action that the corporate defendant knew, or should have known, that Fernandez london and day trips or weekend tours was unlicensed, incompetent, or reckless. Further, Plaintiffs failed to cite any legal authority that ELRAc was under an obligation to check Fernandez's driver's record beyond verifying that he had a valid driver's license (see generally, Vedder v. Cox, 18 Misc 3d 1142 [A] (Sup. Ct. Nassau 2008]).
Based upon the foregoing, the Court finds that Plaintiffs failed to state a cause of action against the corporate Defendant. Likewise, the Court determines that Plaintiffs' did not allege a claim independent of Vehicle Traffic Law 388. [FN7] Beyond checking to make sure that a renter has a valid driver's license,a rental car company is not obligated to check the renter's driving history or record, london and day trips or weekend tours according to this court, london and day trips or weekend tours in order to qualify for the vicarious liability london and day trips or weekend tours claim-preclusive protection of the Graves Amendment.
Readers -- When the New York State Insurance Department became the Department of Financial Services london and day trips or weekend tours on October 3, 2011, links on this blog to NYSID webpages were broken. Since all old links resolve to a "Not Found" page with a www.dfs.ny.gov/ address, however, one needs only insert " insurance/ " after the "...gov/" in the "Not Found" page address to get to the desired page.
Welcome to Coverage Counsel , where we hope you will find timely and useful information london and day trips or weekend tours regarding New York state and federal insurance coverage cases and issues. Coverage Counsel is brought to you by the law firm of MURA STORM, PLLC with a main office in Buffalo, New York. To contact london and day trips or weekend tours us, call (716) 855-2800 or email Roy Mura , the editor of this blawg.
To receive automatic email updates to Coverage Counsel once a week on Tuesdays, enter your email address and click "Subscribe Me", which will take you to another page. Once you verify your email address london and day trips or weekend tours by clicking the link in a confirmation email that will be sent to your inbox, you will begin receiving email updates weekly IF there are any new postings. Thanks for your interest in Coverage Counsel !
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ (c) 2009. First, let me congratulate you on finding this disclaimer, all the way down here at the bottom of this page. You're either very thorough, or very bored. Or both. Either way, this is where I tell you that what I post on this blog or blawg is not intended and should not be considered to be legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed either from your finding your way to these pages, posting comments, or receiving comments in reply. If you need or want legal advice, you're welcome to contact and retain me, especially if your question is one relating to insurance coverage. If quality and correctness are optional to you, however, just turn on a TV, open a newspaper, or take a drive along a nearby highway and jot the numbers down of lawyers who probably don't blawg but spend gobs and gobs more on advertising than I do. Although I try my best to keep the material on these pages current, I cannot promise that all case decisions, statutes and hyperlinks will always be up-to-date. Same goes for content accuracy. I'm nearly, london and day trips or weekend tours but not always, perfect. Please report dead links or overruled or superseded case decisions london and day trips or weekend tours to me by clicking here. Although comments are moderated, london and day trips or weekend tours I take no responsibility for and do not endorse the viewpoints expressed by this blawg's commenters. The viewpoints and opinions I may myself express in this blawg from time to time are my own and do not necessarily reflect more than one-half of the official position london and day trips or weekend tours of the law firm of Mura Storm, PLLC. For the record, I respect all judges, named or unnamed in these posts, though not always their judicial acumen or composition. I reserve the right to revise my thinking and recant my occasional disagreement with the logic or language of a court's decision, especially if IAS matches me with any of the mildly maligned magistrates in one of my clients' litigated matters. Thanks london and day trips or weekend tours for stopping by. Mura Storm, PLLC 930 Rand Building, 14 Lafayette Square london and day trips or weekend tours Buffalo, New York 14203 (716) 855-2800 -- Voice (716) 855-2816 -- Fax Get Directions